gordana
Full Member
The larger the island of knowledge, the longer the shoreline of wonder.
Posts: 128
|
Post by gordana on Jul 6, 2022 23:35:55 GMT
Is sensitive to noise, which causes nervousness, has various types of bleeding that are often associated with nausea.
Let me start where I left off, with a gentle warm-up. I believe this is pretty easy. I apologize in advance if I don't respond quickly to your answers. I try to get back on several tracks at the same time.
|
|
|
Post by Admin - Joy Lucas on Jul 24, 2022 15:37:03 GMT
oversensitive to noise is a huge rubric and you would always include big rubrics, why not, however the reaction is that of becoming nervous from noise so possibly 'anxiety from noise' would have to be a starting point as well as 'painful sensitivity to noise' which has much fewer remedies.
confirming rubric would be to study haemorrhage associated with nausea which is much more curious and uncommon and this would be the leading rubric
and then you'd need something to decide between Arnica or Ipecac
Welcome back Madame G - there are only ghosts here :-)
|
|
gordana
Full Member
The larger the island of knowledge, the longer the shoreline of wonder.
Posts: 128
|
Post by gordana on Jul 24, 2022 21:10:02 GMT
"and then you'd need something to decide between Arnica or Ipecac" straight to the center (you have an idiom in English that reads something like "bull's eye") I'll think about what to use from the symptoms, so that we can have a little longer fun. "Welcome back Madame G - there are only ghosts here :-)" thank you, Madame Teacher. always a pleasure to be in your company. so we are alone here. if we do not count the partially visible and inaudible entities.
|
|
|
Post by Admin - Joy Lucas on Jul 25, 2022 6:35:25 GMT
😬
Yes let’s keep the fun going somehow
|
|
gordana
Full Member
The larger the island of knowledge, the longer the shoreline of wonder.
Posts: 128
|
Post by gordana on Jul 27, 2022 21:34:05 GMT
It is not very funny to have a fun little longer at this occasion. Let's try to learn a bit more, since you already knew two main remedies for differentiation. Although, I don't know who can learn if there is no one here, but since hope was at the bottom of Pandora's box and it is said that it is the last to die, I hope that our discussion will still be useful to someone. If nothing else, the two of us will (as always) have fun. It could be concluded that the two of us are not really interesting company. But, who cares?
So, in the given puzzle, what differentiates Arn from Ipec?
Similarities (by rubrics ie. symptoms)
Ailments from
- Mind; fear; suffocation, of; night: arn ip. (+17 other) - Expectoration; bloody, spitting of blood; cough; without, or effort: arn ip. (+ 9 other) - Stomach; nausea; hemorrhage, with; uterine: arn IP. (+ 5 other)
One-sided
Very interesting to study, related to quinine
Of course, this is only part of the picture. A more extensive analysis would require writing a much more detailed paper. To be continued... In the meantime, I look forward to your questions and thoughts to share with us
|
|
|
Post by Admin - Joy Lucas on Jul 28, 2022 10:26:12 GMT
Most likely the emotional aspects of each remedy would rule out one or the other quite significantly as they are so different - Ip is so morose and/or grumpy whatever the age and Arnica more "I am fine" or otherwise quite fearful in a timid sort of way but can be driven to quite violent outbursts.
Another way to distinguish is through the actual type of haemorrhage. You would always note the type of bleeding in a case, bright, dark, gushing, passive, profuse, scanty, itermittent, sudden etc and also the orifice from which it comes from and the link to the specific organ that is in trouble.
Learning how to differentiate between remedies is vital - it is what we have to do at the end of the case taking, rubric choosing and ultimate end of analysis which gives us usually not just 2 remedies to differentiate between but potentially 10 or even more. This is a required skill in finding the simillimum and shows us how important it is in ranking symptoms of the case - if a remedy comes up in the repping analysis that does not have enough of the top keynotes of the case it can usually be safely ruled out.
|
|
gordana
Full Member
The larger the island of knowledge, the longer the shoreline of wonder.
Posts: 128
|
Post by gordana on Sept 25, 2022 21:27:49 GMT
Yes, I meant Ipecacuanha. An extensive paper could be written here on the differentiation between these two dominant remedies, but I will only address the crucial differences as per your suggestions. When it comes to mood, we can notice a significant difference (besides what you already mentioned). Although both remedies are characterized by a repulsive mood, the ways of manifestation are different, as well as the reasons for such behavior, so we have: - Mind; mood; repulsive: ARN ip. Arnica rejects what is offered to them, even what they asked for, to the extent that person rejects otherwise favorite things (things can be seen in children as for example favorite toys, and in adults they can be not only objects, but also some circumstances, desires, modalities, etc.). Arnica is crying from ailments, anger (during and after), after rage (Knerr), with pain in chest, during and after cough, with difficult respiration (Lippe). Ipecacuanha most frequent has somewhat more pronounced quiet disposition in a mood, although Arnica has it too, but to a lesser extent (if we exclude the state of shock, well known in Arn condition). Ipecacuanha is characterized by a tearful mood in diarrhea, which is not surprising, because Ipec normally covers symptoms related to the pneumogastric nerve, considering that the original plant has the most pronounced effect on that nerve. I will describe more about this in the work started on the fear of vomiting. Ipec cries in toothache (Jahr), has tendency to sob, to violent and irritable weep, and what is especially interesting (at least to me the extremes are always challenging) – on the one hand they can't cry (first we would think of Nat-m, Ign, Ph-ac as well as some salts of Aur), and on the other hand, a very pronounced symptom, at least according to Knerr, they could stay in "incessantly weeping mood" (Puls, Ferr, Ambr, Lyc, Merc, Thuj etc.). In the next post, I will address the bleedings.
|
|
|
Post by Admin - Joy Lucas on Sept 26, 2022 10:19:34 GMT
I would add that the incessant weeping mood correlates to the repulsive mood. There isn’t much about Ipecac that allows for closeness, they tend to repel (I tend to think of arnica being somewhat more gentle but not always) and so the 2 rx are so similar and yet so different, arnica will repel but with the “I’m ok” kind of attitude.
Always so interesting is this thing we call homeopathy 😁
|
|